Boxycharm vs Ipsy – Which Brand is Better?

Ipsy was founded by makeup artist Michele Phan in 2011 with a mission to inspire beauty expression worldwide. The brand offers a range of trial-sized products to help people discover what they love, keep up with trends, and learn more about themselves.

Boxycharm, on the other hand, was created in 2013 by makeup connoisseur turned entrepreneur Joe Martin. He saw a gap in the market for a beauty subscription offering full-sized products at an affordable price, and that’s exactly what he delivered. Boxycharm has since become a popular choice for beauty enthusiasts worldwide.

If you’re a fan of watching beauty gurus on YouTube, you’ve probably come across these two brands. Influencers like KathleenLights and eleventhgorgeous have compared the contents of each box and found them to be filled with unique finds and loved products.

In this review, we’ll give you the lowdown on both Ipsy and Boxycharm, including the different plans, price, value, customer testimonials, and more. We’ll help you decide which box is worth subscribing to.

Ipsy vs Boxycharm: Key Things to Consider

Let’s talk about what to keep in mind before diving into this Ipsy vs Boxycharm review. Here’s what I’ll be focusing on to help you make the right choice:

  • Target Audience: Both Ipsy and Boxycharm are perfect for anyone looking to explore different beauty products, including skincare, haircare, and makeup. They aim to help you discover new things and learn more about beauty and yourself.
  • Customization: Both boxes offer semi-customization, where you can choose one (Boxycharm) or 1-3 (Ipsy) items, and the rest of the products will be chosen based on your selections.
  • Flexibility: You can cancel or pause your subscription anytime, or upgrade your plan for a larger box.
  • Range: Both companies offer a wide range of beauty items, from nail care to skincare to makeup.
  • Accessibility: Both Ipsy and Boxycharm are affordable, and subscribing is easy – just visit their websites!

So, there you have it – the key things to consider before choosing between Ipsy and Boxycharm.

Get The Best Alternative Here

Ipsy Vs Boxycharm: How Do They Work? 

Ipsy and Boxycharm are two subscription services that allow you to try out new beauty products. Here’s how they work:

Boxycharm: You’ll receive 5-6 full-size beauty products, with three different variants for each of the five products. You get to choose one or two items, while the rest are selected based on your choice.

Ipsy: You’ll receive eight items, mostly trial-sized with a few full-sized items, from over 40 different brands every month. Each bag is unique and customized to you based on your answers to a beauty quiz. You can choose 1-3 items to be included in the bag.

Both services offer a fun way to discover new products, but Ipsy has more variety in each box, while Boxycharm offers more consistency each month.

Ipsy Vs Boxycharm: Subscription Plans  

Both brands offer similar monthly subscription plans, with options for a regular and deluxe box, as well as a quarterly super box for members only.

Signing up for Ipsy involves taking a beauty quiz, entering your info and payment details, and waiting for your monthly bag to arrive in a reusable makeup bag. Boxycharm involves choosing a box and a free gift, entering your info, taking a quiz, and waiting for your monthly box to arrive in a recyclable storage box.

Canceling your subscription with either brand is easy, with the option to pause for a month or two with Ipsy. Both brands offer tailored subscriptions and member perks, so you’re sure to find a plan that works for you.

In summary, both Ipsy and Boxycharm offer similar subscription plans with a monthly surprise and the option to tailor your packages to your interests. Plus, you’ll enjoy bonus perks like reusable makeup bags and recyclable storage boxes.

Ipsy Glam Bag Vs Boxycharm Base Review

So, you’re looking to up your beauty game and trying to decide between the Ipsy Glam Bag and Boxycharm Base. No problem! Here’s the lowdown on both.

The Ipsy Glam Bag is a monthly subscription that will get you 5 deluxe trial-sized products, all tucked into a mini makeup bag that’s perfect for on-the-go. You’ll get a mix of makeup and skincare items, with the option to choose one of the items you receive. It’ll run you $13/month.

The Boxycharm Base, on the other hand, is all about full-size products. You’ll receive 5 of them in a variety of options, including makeup brushes, skincare, and haircare. You also get to pick one of the items in your package! It’s a bit pricier at $25/month, but with a total value of up to $175, it’s definitely worth it.

So, which one do you choose? It depends on what you’re looking for. If you want affordability, go for the Ipsy Glam Bag. But if you want full-size products and a higher value, go for the Boxycharm Base.

Get The Best Alternative Here

Ipsy Glam Bag Plus vs Boxycharm Premium Review

Ready to up your monthly pampering game? If you’re weighing between the Ipsy Glam Bag Plus and Boxycharm Premium, here’s a quick rundown to help you choose.

The Ipsy Glam Bag Plus delivers five full-size products in a cute reusable mini drawstring bag. You get to pick three items and two will be a surprise. It’s got a good variety of beauty products and can be worth up to $120, but it costs $28/month.

On the other hand, the Boxycharm Premium box comes with six full-size products and you get to choose two out of the six, with four more as a surprise. It retails for $40/month and the contents could be worth up to $215.

So, which one is a better deal for you? If you’re all about more bang for your buck, the Ipsy bag gives you more products per dollar spent. But if you’re after higher value, the Boxycharm box takes the cake. It’s all up to your personal preferences.

Ipsy vs Boxycharm: A Look at Price and Value

So, you’re thinking about trying out a beauty subscription box but can’t decide between Ipsy and Boxycharm. Don’t worry, we got you.

Both are pretty affordable, with Boxy costing between $25-$60 a month/quarter and Ipsy bags costing between $13-$55 a month/quarter.

At the end of the day, it comes down to personal preference. While one box may have more expensive items, the other might have more products. But, don’t just take our word for it. Customers have been raving about both brands and the high-quality products they receive.

Ipsy bags are a bit cheaper, making it a great starting point if you’re just testing the waters. However, Boxycharm offers more full-size products with each box valued at up to $175. On the other hand, Ipsy often includes smaller, trial-size products.

So, weigh the pros and cons and see which one works for you.

Get The Best Alternative Here

Beauty Subscription Deals: Ipsy vs Boxycharm

This comparison of Ipsy vs Boxycharm is all about the promotions and discounts. Here’s the scoop:


  • Get discounted products when you join
  • Score $3 in add-on credits when you buy a gift card


  • Score a $10 credit and a free gift when you sign up
  • Enjoy membership perks and access to the store
  • Score discounts for longer subscriptions (annual vs monthly)

Both brands offer better deals for longer subscriptions, so it’s a no-brainer if you plan on using the items all year. And don’t forget, there are always promotions happening so finding a deal for your first purchase is a piece of cake.

Ipsy vs Boxycharm: A Customer Review Comparison

Looking to buy a beauty box subscription but can’t decide between Ipsy and Boxycharm? Check out what shoppers are saying! Both brands are popular and have received high ratings on Influenster and Trustpilot.

Ipsy has a 4.3/5 rating based on over 61,000 reviews on Influenster, while Boxycharm has a 4.6/5 rating based on over 27,000 reviews. On Trustpilot, Ipsy received 2.1/5 stars from 207 reviews and Boxycharm earned 3.8/5 stars from 3,189 reviews.

Some common comments about Ipsy include its affordable prices, good variety of products, and a mix of deluxe samples and full-size items. Boxycharm is praised for its high-quality products, variety, and full-size items. Both brands also have responsive customer service and received an “A” grade from the Better Business Bureau.

The reviews are high for both brands because they offer high-quality items at an affordable price and make beauty fun with the element of surprise. Some shoppers have reported receiving repeats, but customer support can resolve the issue.

In summary, both Ipsy and Boxycharm are great choices for beauty box subscriptions!

Get The Best Alternative Here

Ipsy vs Boxycharm: Shipping & Returns Comparison

Currently, both brands only ship within the US and Canada and use fast, tracked shipping from FedEx or DHL.

Ipsy offers free shipping, while Boxycharm charges between $5-$8 for shipping, depending on the box you choose. Ipsy usually ships mid-month, and your goodies should arrive within 7-10 days. With Boxycharm, shipping happens after the first of each month, and your items should arrive within 5-10 days.

Although both brands have faced some shipping delays lately due to the worldwide slowdown, Ipsy’s free shipping is a definite perk. But if you prefer to receive your products closer to the start of the month, then Boxycharm might be the better option for you.

Ipsy vs Boxycharm: A Beauty Box Showdown

They both offer a range of beauty products, but there are a few key differences to keep in mind.

With Ipsy, you’ll get plenty of trial-size products to test out before committing to full-size versions of your favorites. But if you’re more interested in getting a box full of full-size items, Boxycharm might be the way to go.

In the end, both Ipsy and Boxycharm offer great options for trying out new products regularly, with the ability to cancel or restart your subscription at any time. And if you fall in love with a product, you can easily buy it from their websites.

With awesome deals and positive customer reviews, both Ipsy and Boxycharm stand out as top contenders in the beauty box game. The question is, which one (or both!) will you choose to subscribe to first?

Get The Best Alternative Here

Leave a Comment